In partnership with

The Fifty Shades playbook for YOU

There’s a piece of advice filmmakers hear all the time: “Wait until it’s perfect before you release it.”

But if you study how some of the biggest cultural phenomena actually broke through, the opposite is often true.

Take Fifty Shades of Grey.

Whatever you think of the books or the films, the origin story is a playbook indie filmmakers should pay attention to. Because it’s not a story about perfection. It’s a story about putting something out into the world, letting the audience react, and then letting that momentum force the gatekeepers to follow.

What actually happened

Fifty Shades started life as Twilight fan fiction. Author E.L. James, under the pen name Snowqueen’s Icedragon, posted it chapter by chapter on fan fiction sites between 2009 and 2011. At that stage it was called Master of the Universe. It wasn’t polished. It wasn’t publishable in a legal sense, because it used Stephenie Meyer’s characters. But it was out there.

When the explicit content started drawing pushback, James pulled it off fanfiction.net, rewrote it with original characters (Anastasia and Christian instead of Bella and Edward), and self released it through a tiny Australian digital imprint, The Writer’s Coffee Shop, in 2011. It was available as an e-book and print-on-demand paperback.

Readers passed it around. Book bloggers picked it up. Within months, it had sold around a quarter of a million copies, without a major publisher, without bookstores, without marketing muscle.

And then the tide turned. In early 2012, Vintage Books (Random House) swooped in, bought the rights, and re-released the trilogy. Not long after, Universal and Focus Features paid as much as $5 million for the film rights.

The books went on to sell more than 100 million copies worldwide. The films grossed about $1.3 billion at the box office.

But all of that, the book deals, the studio deal, the billion dollar franchise, came after the fact. It started with a fanfic uploaded online and an indie e-book release.

Why this matters for you

The obvious question is, what does a fanfiction turned billion dollar franchise have to do with your indie film?

Everything.

Because it shows the power of releasing something ,even if it’s not “perfect” or blessed by the system.

If James had waited until a publisher approved her story, Fifty Shades never would have existed. It wasn’t publishable in its original form. The gatekeepers had already said “no.” But once readers said “yes,” the gatekeepers had no choice but to catch up.

That sequence matters. Audience first, gatekeepers second.

Don’t wait for perfection

This is where the lesson hits filmmakers hardest.

We’ve all heard filmmakers say, “I don’t want to release my movie yet, it’s not perfect.”

Perfect is not what creates momentum. People connect with energy, with emotion, with something that feels alive. Audiences don’t need you to hand them a flawless diamond. They need something that makes them feel.

For E.L. James, that meant rough fanfiction chapters posted online. For you, that might mean uploading your feature to TVOD, or putting it on a niche streamer, or even releasing a cut on YouTube.

That’s your e-book. That’s your print-on-demand paperback. A way to test your film in the wild, gather data, and prove that the story connects.

“Unpolished but alive” beats “perfect but unseen”

250,000 copies sold as an indie e-book. Then Vintage. Then Universal. Then a billion dollar film trilogy.

It didn’t start with polish. It started with exposure. Make a mess, but share the mess/

For you, that means your “rough cut” or your “smaller release” can be the thing that creates heat. If you wait five years for perfection, you might miss your moment. But if you put it out, however small, you give it the chance to gather momentum.

Gatekeepers don’t care about hypotheticals. They care about evidence. E.L. James had evidence, hundreds of thousands of readers before any publisher signed her. Your evidence can be view counts, watch-time, festival buzz, even small licensing deals.

That’s what makes people pay attention.

Clear the rights, then be bold

One important caveat, E.L. James had to re-author her story before it could ever be sold. She changed the names, rewrote the characters, and stripped it of Twilight’s IP before it became Fifty Shades.

That’s an important reminder for you, be bold, but don’t be careless. You can’t just grab someone else’s copyrighted world and expect to sell it. But here’s where things get interesting, public domain. I think of it as an interesting starting point.

Look at Winnie the Pooh. When the copyright expired, we suddenly got Winnie the Pooh: Blood and Honey, a horror reimagining. Or take Mickey Mouse: the earliest version of Steamboat Willie has just entered the public domain, and you can bet we’re going to see people experimenting with new takes. That’s perfectly legal because the material is now free to adapt.

That’s the difference. You can start with something as inspiration, but if you want to own it, you have to re-shape it into your own IP. Just like James swapped out Edward and Bella for Christian and Ana, you can change character names, tweak settings, reframe the story, and suddenly it goes from being based on someone else’s property to being yours.

Don’t be afraid of using IP out there as fan fiction or public domain content as a base, just to give you a path to get your story going. Once the story is complete, then you can go back and make adjustments so that it is yours.

Once you’ve cleared those rights, or built something wholly original, don’t wait for permission. Put it into the world and let the audience decide.

Publish to people, not to perfection

The core of the Fifty Shades playbook is simple, publish to people, not to perfection.

Your audience is the real greenlight. They’re the ones who decide whether something matters, whether it spreads, whether gatekeepers have to follow.

And audiences don’t care if it’s rough around the edges. They care if it moves them.

You don’t have to love Fifty Shades to see the lesson in its success.

It started as fanfiction on a website. It became a cultural juggernaut because readers, not publishers, made it matter.

Don’t wait for polish, don’t wait for permission. Put your film into the world and let the audience decide.

Because gatekeepers can’t ignore numbers.

And the only way to get numbers is to get your work out there.

PS: If you want to go deeper, the Filmmaker Lab is the easiest way to fund your film and avoid the traps that stall most indie projects. Details here: FILMMAKING LAB & COURSE

PPS: I also keep a few spots open each month for 30-minute Clarity Sessions. They’re focused on helping you get unstuck, make sharper decisions, and leave with a tailored blueprint. If you’re interested, reply to this email.

PPPS: Do you run a company, brand, or film festival? Want to get in front of nearly 3,000 indie filmmakers each week? Sponsorships for this newsletter are available, details here: SPONSOR THE MOVIE REVOLUTION NEWSLETTER